4: Stick Shift Vs. Automatic

It's time to choose a side. Are you with Penalty or Lloyd? join a team, then join the fite!


  • Todd wrote on July 24, 11:40 am

    Hah, I can say id never have Penalty or Lloyd as my wingman. Looks like they have a tendency to scare guests off!

  • Jules Benne (guest) wrote in reply on August 1, 9:19 pm

    Just another dumb blond. Yo, sweetheart, "id" is spelled 'eyed.' Thanks for sharing.

  • Stephen (guest)(team penalty) wrote in reply on August 7, 6:45 am

    no its i'd

  • AlecTheLloydSlayer(team penalty) wrote in reply on August 12, 5:54 am

    Rong speling rulez...

  • WesChard(team penalty) wrote on July 24, 11:04 pm

    Automatic... All I have to say...

  • ATB-dante wrote in reply on November 18, 2:30 am

    gotta agree with penalty there

  • Fishes(team penalty) wrote on July 24, 11:06 pm

    Penalty's got it. Too much work stick shift is.

  • Redswater (guest)(team lloyd) wrote in reply on July 24, 11:08 pm

    i bet you drive a hybrid

  • Fishes(team penalty) wrote in reply on July 25, 10:53 am

    If i do, whats your point? It gets me from point A to point B, thats all i need.

  • dakaf_fal(team penalty) wrote in reply on July 29, 9:54 pm

    -Hey, I bet you drive a hybrid!
    -It's part exciting, part safe.

    and of course "Starburst- thanks for sharing!"

  • Redswater (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 24, 11:07 pm

    Stick... JUST FOR THE THRILL

  • BandwidthYay wrote on July 24, 11:08 pm

    Automatic for life. I'm with Penalty on this one

  • NikoAnesti(team penalty) wrote on July 24, 11:08 pm

    I'm with Penalty. Stick is okay, but I'd much rather drive automatic. It's just easier. Not to mention Penalty has about the same skills with the ladies that I do. Great episode this week!

  • z31ftw (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 24, 11:25 pm

    STICK SHIFT WTFX? if you have any driving skill whatsoever driving stick is infinitely superior! you have much more control over the vehicle. and it's badass.

  • doodletime(team lloyd) wrote on July 24, 11:27 pm

    Pfft...auto is for just the daily mindless commute to work. If you've ever driven anything with even an iota of performance value, you would understand there is a reason for manually shifting the transmission.
    Ex. Bugatti Veyron. Nuff said.

    P.S. I love Dan, but Penalty needs to grow a pair ;)

  • Thorbie(team lloyd) wrote in reply on July 24, 11:32 pm

    I agree. Penalty has turned from a middle aged heavy metal fan to a hybrid driving hippie since the first nite fite meth minute. Lloyd's been stealing the show since then.

  • Andy Merrill (guest)(team lloyd) wrote in reply on July 25, 9:00 pm

    I couldn't have said it better myself. There are numerous reasons why high performance and top of the line automobiles.

    Better fuel economy (for several reasons that I won't explain because most people probably won't care or understand)
    They are lighter (in weight) than automatics
    They are less expensive
    Much more efficient
    A huge increase in the driver's control of the vehicle
    It requires that you pay more attention, discouraging irresponsible driving
    Most manuals can push start if your battery dies

    The advantages FAR outweigh the disadvantages, many of which are no longer valid once the driver has enough experience with a stick shift. And any new driver will have difficulty driving a car regardless of the type of transmission.

  • Thorbie(team lloyd) wrote on July 24, 11:29 pm

    Automatics and hybrids are why this country is heading for a recession! Linda Weiss proved Lloyd's point! Are you guys blind?

  • Rush_is_Metal(team penalty) wrote on July 24, 11:31 pm

    Automaic is the way to go, peopel driving stick are just slowing down th epeople of america!

  • Andy Merrill (guest)(team lloyd) wrote in reply on July 25, 9:05 pm

    I can guarantee you that if you take the same car, one with auto and one with manual, take two drivers of equal skill in both types of transmissions, and had them clock 0-60, the manual would win every time. The power distribution from the engine to the wheels is far superior to that of an automatic. That's a proven fact.

  • BigT387 (guest) wrote in reply on October 3, 9:12 pm

    only people who can't drive for sh*t are slower with a stick shift because they don't know how, if your good at it no one can really tell if it is a stick.

  • SexyChocolateLover (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 24, 11:39 pm

    Ahh, I wish I knew how to drive stick, all the ladies like that. Stick is therefore better.

  • anarkist(team penalty) wrote in reply on July 25, 3:12 am

    Stick shifts are too much work, and you can still get plenty of power out of an automatic transmission if you want it.

  • Tim(team penalty) wrote on July 24, 11:41 pm

    Part exciting, part safe... hybrids FTW!

  • Timor(team lloyd) wrote on July 25, 12:16 am

    Haha "linda" means pretty in spanish and.....if automatic didn't kill America, it's certainly killing Canada!

  • Jules Benne (guest) wrote in reply on August 1, 9:27 pm

    It means 'beautiful' Dumas! Perty is "Bonita."

  • Nico (guest)(team lloyd) wrote in reply on August 5, 11:33 am

    I prefer stick shift, but I respect people who like to drive AT, I live in a city with heavy traffic, and sometimes I wish I had an AT vehicle, but MT is A LOT better for uphill and downhill driving as it gives you more control over the car, wich is important if you have a small car with small engine.
    Linda or bonita can both be translated as pretty... beautiful would be "hermosa"... I don´t see the point on insulting people over such a little detail.

  • Justinsuperstar(team lloyd) wrote on July 25, 12:41 am

    Automatic is for the WEAK!

  • Eggo Waffle(team lloyd) wrote in reply on July 25, 12:44 am

    Save america, drive stick!

  • fivethumbsdown(team penalty) wrote on July 25, 12:48 am

    Automatic, I use my car to get from point A to point B.

    I don't use it in illegal street racing, if I did, I'd use stick shift.

  • Leon (guest)(team lloyd) wrote in reply on July 25, 12:52 am

    You're killing america

  • Jules Benne (guest) wrote in reply on August 1, 9:31 pm

    Then try running next time. It looks like you could use the exercise. And it'll reduce your carbon footprint, so your next pair of shoes will need less leather to make them.

  • Ten-High Charlie (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 25, 1:17 am

    Stick. Its just so much cooler.

  • Kitsunexus(team penalty) wrote on July 25, 1:22 am

    I agree with 5thumbsdown, AT for everyday stuff, manual for racing.

  • andrew (guest) wrote on July 25, 1:57 am

    Stick shift, nothing like taking control of you life one gear at a time. Automatics are great for drag racing, but doing the 1320 ft with a stick shift is a man's job

  • IamCanadian(team lloyd) wrote on July 25, 2:00 am

    Stick Shifts. I like hybrids, but Stick shifts just appeal to me more.

  • liece (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 25, 3:08 am

    moooooooooooooore!!!!!!!!

  • weker1 (guest) wrote on July 25, 4:06 am

    Side note Stick shifts are stolen far less then automatics!
    How ever Stick shifts are Vandalised More due to The Would be Car thief getting pissed that it's a stick.
    Most people can't drive sticks.
    ok I'ma put my nerd away now.

  • Ro@m(team lloyd) wrote on July 25, 6:17 am

    Stick shift

  • Melvinthebarbarian (guest) wrote on July 25, 7:46 am

    Molly SIMMS? Not _THE_ Molly Simms?!

    http://www.mollysims.com/

  • Lindsey (guest)(team penalty) wrote on July 25, 11:23 am

    AUTOMATIC!!!!! The only reason you'd drive stick shift is to go fast, and switch gears at your own will. I like driving slow.

  • stickftw (guest)(team lloyd) wrote in reply on August 1, 2:32 pm

    Stick FTW!!! Manual is for 60+ year olds or people who have only one hand.
    O and btw if your thinking of buying a hybrid just because they "consume less fuel" they dont, they are even worst than a similar non hybrid car.
    http://www.wheels.ca/article/31204

  • gpMan (guest) wrote in reply on August 1, 9:36 pm

    It's 'slowly' not "slow" you ignorant American! No wonder you broke away the Brits; you couldn't learn the language.

  • I'm An American (guest) wrote on July 25, 11:49 am

    Sweetie, could I have more Nite Fite please.

  • CEsAR (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 25, 12:17 pm

    manual its for people who really drive a car
    automatic its for grannies and its killing america

  • KAT-S13 (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 25, 1:40 pm

    stick gets the chick... nuff said!

  • TheJake(team penalty) wrote on July 25, 2:24 pm

    stick shift vs. automatic? its all about personal opinion, its too much of a grey area to decide officially which is "better". some people like stick shift because its "more fun" or whatever, but others like automatic because its easier and requires less effort and focus, so they can also focus on driving safely, or whatever they need to be focusing on. i personally perfer automatic, because its easier.

  • iLikePieBitch!(team penalty) wrote on July 25, 2:25 pm

    Automatic, its EZer

  • Ben (guest)(team penalty) wrote on July 25, 2:29 pm

    She's beautiful.

  • Hehehenerd (guest) wrote on July 25, 2:59 pm

    Automatic.....but only cause I need to get my driver license as easy as possible

  • gpsrule (guest) wrote in reply on August 1, 9:41 pm

    It's 'more easily,' not"easy." But anyway, take the stick, it's more easier to learn to dryve.

  • Mr.Grave (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 25, 3:15 pm

    Stick shift....faster!

  • Tina(team penalty) wrote on July 25, 5:32 pm

    I can't drive... but I think Auto would be easier... right?

  • Rivek (guest)(team penalty) wrote on July 25, 7:41 pm

    Auto is easier and less annoying in the city. Stick shifts are good for only one thing - the first 45 seconds of a long stretch of highway.

  • gpsrit (guest) wrote in reply on August 1, 9:44 pm

    And the last 45 seconds to get the car into the garage before the police make that last turn into your neighborhood!

  • Taylor Abrahamse (guest) wrote on July 25, 7:47 pm

    I know they've only got a week to make a short, but with the Starburst money can they hire some more animators and make something maybe 30 seconds longer w/some detail? That may be going against what they're trying to achieve but I really don't know which side to pick. But this whole thing is a great idea.

  • zach (guest) wrote on July 25, 11:29 pm

    the linda weiss cartoon has small boobs ={

  • O (guest) wrote in reply on August 1, 9:46 pm

    Zach,
    Get your mind out of the gutter. Her boobs are still bigger than your brain, though.

  • Rhett (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 26, 3:44 am

    Stick Shift is right. You have better control of your transmission. You have to be an idiot to not know how to drive a stick shift.

  • hikaruchan0(team lloyd) wrote on July 26, 5:56 pm

    Manual is the only way to go they are lighter and faster but the new twin cluch squentual manual gearboxis found in the new Mitsubichi EVO 10 & Nissan GTR witch in the case of the GTR can change in 0.2 of a second I would not mind having ether.

  • jmanbassdude(team lloyd) wrote on July 27, 12:55 am

    I am SOOO with Lloyd!!!! STICK ROX!!!!!!

  • Chris (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 27, 1:34 pm

    People keep using the term "easy" to describe automatics. Is that how this country is heading? Are we becoming so lazy and fat that shifting a manual tranmission has become too diffilcult and tiresome. Please tell me it isnt so. And manuals do encourage the driver to focus on the task at hand, which is driving, not eating, not talking on the phone or the worst one of all - texting.

  • The_REAL_Lloyd(team lloyd) wrote in reply on July 29, 10:16 am

    You are a true American hero, Chris. I, Lloyd, salute you.

  • MIKEEEY (guest)(team penalty) wrote on July 27, 2:12 pm

    Yea I REALLY want to have keep one hand on the friign transmission and hit the friggin clutch every time I need to change a gear - the hell with that noise: AUTOMAATIIICCCC FOR THE WIN

  • Pablo (guest) wrote on July 27, 7:36 pm

    Stick shift is better ina big number of ways, but most ppl like automatic because they can do everything else except pay attention to the road or move their articulations. Stick is cooler,cheaper,you save gas, get more power from engine and if battery dies you can start it anyway!

  • Pablo (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 27, 7:37 pm

    Stick shift is better ina big number of ways, but most ppl like automatic because they can do everything else except pay attention to the road or move their articulations. Stick is cooler,cheaper,you save gas, get more power from engine and if battery dies you can start it anyway!

  • Henry (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 28, 11:52 am

    if u can drive a car u drive it manual or flap paddle gearbox
    thend

  • Billy (guest) wrote on July 28, 3:35 pm

    Hi there. Perhaps you guys could, oh, I don't know.. Debate about things a little more "in-depth"? I love the enthusiasm of the show, but I want to see more arguing. More opinions. More fighting. Please and thank you.

  • The_REAL_Lloyd(team lloyd) wrote in reply on July 29, 10:14 am

    This is "in-depth" sir. There is nothing more in-depth than the hard charging action of Nite Fite. I would know, I'm the one charging. If you'd get your head out of a book for once and listen, you'd know that.
    ps - thank you for watching
    pps - and buying Starburst products

  • STEFAZON(team penalty) wrote on July 28, 4:07 pm

    Manual rocks, automatic is for lazy people

  • Pietacular(team penalty) wrote on July 28, 5:21 pm

    Auto all the way. Manual is too awkward.

  • o8jedi(team penalty) wrote on July 28, 7:01 pm

    I concede that stick is more fun. However, those automatic transmissions that you can kinda do a stick shift take the best of both worlds. Since it's really an automatic in disguise, Penalty wins.

  • phizzlepimp(team penalty) wrote on July 29, 10:59 pm

    stick shift is for guys that need to make up for somthing else down below.

  • The REAL Penalty(team penalty) wrote in reply on July 30, 11:05 am

    Just Like Lloyd. May I also remind you that he needs to make up for something ABOVE (hint: his brain!)

  • The_REAL_Lloyd(team lloyd) wrote in reply on July 30, 5:12 pm

    You should know, Penalty, about making up for something ABOVE. No hint needed: You're bald!

  • Michaelbak (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 30, 1:55 pm

    I have to go with Lioyd i think Automatic and Hybrids are killing America!

  • HOODSY (guest)(team penalty) wrote in reply on August 17, 8:03 am

    UR POLITICIANS ARE KILLING YOU!!!

  • Sngamer (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 31, 11:03 am

    Manual FTW

  • Jenniqua wrote on July 31, 12:03 pm

    I am a 42 year old woman and I can parallel park on a hill in San Francisco with a STICK.

  • ryan scott (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on July 31, 5:29 pm

    when is the next nite fite

  • noeggroll (guest) wrote on August 1, 5:42 am

    i am actually neutral stick .. i remember stick but those who havent driven stick as they grew up dont know really how it was i can see how many hate shift where i can see where many hate automatics so im w/ no one on this one

  • Skate Baker (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on August 2, 10:23 am

    Stick shift for the win friends, especially if you enjoy driving.

  • csm wrote on August 3, 10:17 am

    Hmmmm

  • nastyprisms(team penalty) wrote on August 5, 8:48 pm

    NITE FITE used to be about the music. penalty and lloyd have lost their way... transmission? bermuda triangle? patriotic popsicles? i mean common!

    lets get to the real issues, like john cougar vs john mellencamp? parliament vs funkadelic? beck vs jeff beck? velvet underground vs velvet revolver?

  • HOODSY (guest)(team penalty) wrote in reply on August 17, 8:02 am

    IS UR HEAD REALLY THAT FAR UP UR ASS?

  • nastyprisms (guest)(team penalty) wrote in reply on August 22, 10:21 am

    indeed

  • Hendrik (guest) wrote on August 6, 4:23 pm

    well i don't realy care cause i don't have licence , i m underage . i m 16...
    I try to go driving scool and make the baby driver licence....
    Sticksifth is good cause it's mecanical?
    or auto , u don't need to worry about enge blown

  • BigT387 (guest) wrote in reply on October 3, 9:16 pm

    why bother arguing then

  • ILovesIt(team lloyd) wrote on August 9, 11:16 pm

    Damn I love penalty.....but stick shifts are the SHIT!

  • ILovesIt(team lloyd) wrote on August 9, 11:20 pm

    part exciting, part safe. lol..... i think not

  • atilla the hun wrote on August 11, 8:01 am

    you know ONE of the most important things we need to know is what type of car injured mr freeman i think that is the way to win this debate

  • Ushi (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on August 11, 9:38 pm

    I agree with Lloyd automatic cars are making driving a car a mindless task requiring hardly any skill at all! plus hybrid driver are just idiots who think they're saving the world from global warming by driving the ir prius and shopping at whole foods im gonna laugh in a few tears when all the hybrid drivers have to change their batery costing them a couple thousand dollars and wasting many natural resources and adding to the lie of fuel efficiency just think about how many non renewable energy sources!

  • STICK MAN!! (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on August 14, 10:58 pm

    STICK FTW!!!!!

  • Gigith(team lloyd) wrote on August 17, 7:29 am

    Last 6 words were the best.

  • HOODSY (guest)(team penalty) wrote on August 17, 8:00 am

    iF YA CAN'T DRIVE A MANUAL THEN U AREN'T REALLY DRIVING

  • obeythecheese35(team penalty) wrote on August 19, 11:58 am

    AUTOMATIC FOR THE WIN!!!

  • Mxernadman wrote on August 24, 4:15 am

    Alright guys, traditionally I'm with Loyd on this one. The manual transmission takes the cake of manliness.

    But if they had let Linda Weiss continue talking, we would have learned that the continuous variable transmission (CVT) is superior to both the automatic transmission and the manual transmission for performance.

    The CVT transmission has an effectively infinite number of gear ratios whereas your typical AT and MT might have six.

    What does this mean? The transmission seamlessly changes the gear ratio, effectively keeping the engine in its power band all the time, (the only reason for driving a MT is to help keep the engine in the power band,) without the operator having to shift.

    The end result is a faster and more efficient vehicle. The only drawback: Not being able to break the tires loose when shifting into second gear.

  • Valencia(team penalty) wrote on August 31, 3:13 pm

    Automatic all the way! Who wants a stickshift anyway? Why should driving be difficult with a stupid stickshift? Stickshifts are killing America!With gas prices today, HYBRIDS KICK BUTT!

  • BigT387 (guest) wrote in reply on October 3, 9:13 pm

    stick is easy, unless u suck

  • jenmaire(team lloyd) wrote on September 6, 4:37 am

    I have totally been with Penalty on the first 3 issues, but on this one, just by car ownership and great gas mileage alone (and not really by overwhelming debate winning me over by Lloyd) I am going for Stick Shift!!! Yeah!

  • Demonica (guest)(team penalty) wrote on September 9, 4:28 am

    Automatic ALL the way, I tried doing the ones where you shift it yourself totally suck thats all I got to say.

  • BigT387 (guest) wrote in reply on October 3, 9:12 pm

    haha u can't drive

  • POO (guest) wrote on September 16, 6:53 pm

    I like cheese

  • roockstar(team penalty) wrote on September 20, 12:59 pm

    automatic's killing america., that's so hilarious :D plus automatic is the most comfortable way to drive a car, no matter if it's hybrid or not

  • BigT387 (guest) wrote on October 3, 9:07 pm

    TO BE PART OF THIS ARGUMENT, YOU SOULD HAVE OR AT LEAST BE ABLE TO DRIVE A STICK, OTHER WISE YOUR PREFERENCE IS MEANINGLESS. Stick is more involved and effeciant, automatic is easier.

  • olivia (guest) wrote on October 6, 6:30 am

    hey guys i dont agree with neither but what i think u should do for a episode plz i beg u to do one about the culture of manga and printed media in japan with the voice of the english haruhi suzumiya 11 yr old pre teen begging here

  • St185guy (guest) wrote in reply on October 12, 5:21 pm

    @olivia. Shut up you weeaboo, I don't want to hear about what a kowaii morning you had. You're a sickness on the American cultural landscape. How about you create something and revitalize the nature of graphic novels here in the states? Have you ever even picked up western comics like Transmetropolitan, or 100 Bullets?
    Your otaku obsession pisses off Americans, and real japanese people consider you an insult.

    Let me put this out there to all the haters. There isn't anything wrong with liking anime and manga. its when you start begging for attention regarding it in situations that don't call for it, like olivia did here.

    Kid i may sound harsh, but if you take my advice on this, you're going to end up a LOT better.

  • Iuel (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on October 11, 8:26 pm

    Autamatis is for dickss!!

  • St185guy (guest)(team lloyd) wrote on October 12, 5:14 pm

    Lloyd is completely right on this one. Automatic transmission is the death of driving competency in america. Thanks to the automatic transmission, we've removed the driver from the act of driving. This leads to a dangerous situation, namely that driving becomes a chore to be done, rather than an experience to be enjoyed. Now that the driver's participation in driving has been reduced, most drivers find a way to fill the gap in their attention span, with goddamn cell phones. I can't EVEN begin to tell you how many times I've nearly been creamed by idiot drivers on phones, not looking where they're going, changing lanes without signaling, and slamming on brakes at the last minute. Cellphones are fast rising to the level of drunk driver in terms of dangers on the road. Worst of all is people TEXTING while driving. I don't give a damn if your mother is shitting herself to death, YOU DO NOT TEXT THAT OLD HAG ON THE ROAD. This needs to be an offense that ends in license revocation. NO EXCEPTIONS.

    And the only reason you morons can TEXT and PHONE while driving, is because of the automatic transmission. Thats right. The automatic transmission is an accomplice to at least hundreds of american deaths EVERY. SINGLE.YEAR.
    Teach your kids to respect the road. Teach them stick!

  • Sarge(team lloyd) wrote on November 4, 11:55 pm

    Stick is faster

  • TheCriticalThinker#1 (guest) wrote on November 12, 12:20 pm

    Manual save fuel and perfect for short distance driving as in street to street

    Automatic consume more fuel than manual but it's perfect if you are in a Traffic conjestion or long distance driving.

Rate This:

Hot topic of the night: Stick Shift vs. Automatic Transmission. There's only one right answer here and Penalty and Lloyd are going to find it - with help from their beautiful expert guest.

Episodes